Contents · 14 min read
Two models, one question
A «lead», in marketing jargon, is a person who has asked to be contacted: a private individual who filled in a quote request form, left their number, described their need. When this request is passed on to you, there are two models. Either it is delivered only to you: this is called an exclusive lead. Or it can be delivered to several companies in the same trade and the same area: this is called a shared lead.
Neither model is good or bad in itself. An exclusive lead usually costs more per unit, but you are the only one calling the person back. A shared lead usually costs less, but other companies call the same person back, sometimes before you. The question to ask is therefore not «which one is best?», but «which one gives me the lowest cost per signed customer, given the way I work?»
This article compares the two models without defending either. It shows what changes for the price, the signing rate and the way you call back, then gives a method for choosing, the habits that lead to more signatures when the contact is shared, and the clauses to read in a contract before committing.
The comparison table
| Criterion | Exclusive lead | Shared lead |
|---|---|---|
| Who receives the request | Only you, for the agreed trade and area | Several companies in the same trade and area, according to the number set by the provider |
| Unit price | Usually higher | Usually lower |
| Competition for the same person | None from the provider; the person can always look elsewhere | Direct: other companies call the same person back |
| Pressure on call-back time | Strong in emergency trades, weaker for projects | Very strong: whoever calls back first often has the advantage |
| Signing rate to expect | Higher, all other things being equal | Lower, the more so as the number of companies grows |
| What makes the difference | The quality of the call-back, the quote and the time to start work | The speed of call-back, then the quality of the quote |
| Commitment in the contract | Often an option, linked to conditions (area, trade, balance or volume) | Often more flexible |
| Better suited to | A company that cannot call back within minutes, or that sells considered projects | A company organised to call back very quickly, with a fast quote |
Descriptive table: differences in price and signing rate vary by provider, trade and area.
Two lines sum up the essentials. The price line and the signing rate line move in opposite directions: what a shared lead saves on price, it often loses on signatures. The result depends on the balance between the two, and that balance depends largely on you, on how fast you call back and how clear your quote is.
An important point: exclusivity concerns the way the provider distributes the request, not the person themselves. A private individual who needs a quote may very well ask for another one elsewhere, through another site, a neighbour, a directory. An exclusive lead reduces competition coming from the channel; it does not remove it.
What a signed customer costs in each case
The cost of a signed customer is always calculated the same way: the price of a contact divided by the share of contacts you sign. What changes with sharing is that share. When several companies receive the same person, the person signs with only one of them, and the split depends a great deal on the order in which they call back.
The chart below models this effect with written assumptions. It varies the number of companies receiving the same contact, from one to five, and draws three curves: you call back first, you call back in the middle, you call back last. The prices and shares are round assumptions, not market averages.
The chart shows three things. First, the company that always calls back first pays roughly the same price per customer, whether the contact is exclusive or shared: the lower price offsets the competition. Second, the company that calls back in the middle sees its cost per customer rise with the number of companies on the same contact. Third, the company that calls back last pays a very high price for its customers as soon as the contact is shared.
The conclusion is not that one model is better than the other. It is that a shared lead rewards speed, and that an exclusive lead protects those who cannot call back within minutes: a sole tradesperson on a job, a company without a phone line staffed at all times, a trade where you cannot pick up with your hands full. Choosing the model starts with an honest look at how you call back today.
Why call-back speed matters so much
The most quoted study on the subject was carried out in 2007 by an MIT researcher with the company InsideSales.com. It covers more than 15 000 contacts and more than 100 000 call attempts in six American companies. Its results are clear: the chances of reaching a person were a hundred times lower if they were called 30 minutes after their request rather than 5 minutes after, and the chances of qualifying them twenty-one times lower. Source: Lead Response Management Study, MIT and InsideSales.com
The study is old, American, and does not concern trades. It would be wrong to draw a figure for Switzerland from it. But the mechanism it describes is easy to understand without statistics: a person who has just filled in a form still has their problem in mind, their phone in hand, and has not yet spoken to anyone else. An hour later, they may be in a meeting, driving, or already booking an appointment with the company that called back first.
With an exclusive lead, this mechanism works against the other channels the person may have used at the same time. With a shared lead, it also works against the other companies that received exactly the same request at the same moment. That is why call-back speed matters even more in the second model.
When to choose one or the other
An exclusive lead is often preferable if…
- you work alone or with one other person, and cannot call back while on a job;
- your jobs are considered projects (roofing, renovation, pools) where the quality of the first conversation matters more than the minute saved;
- you want a stable relationship with an area, building your reputation in a few municipalities;
- the volume of requests for your trade in your area is low, and you do not want to share it.
A shared lead may be preferable if…
- you have a staffed phone line or someone in the office who calls back within minutes;
- your trade is an emergency trade where people choose whoever can come fastest;
- you can produce a simple quote the same day;
- you are looking for volume at a low unit price, and accept losing part of it.
Many companies combine the two: exclusivity in the area where they are based and want to build a reputation, sharing in neighbouring areas where they take jobs when the schedule allows. What counts is measuring the two separately, to know what a customer really costs in each.
Signing more with a shared lead
If you work with shared leads, three habits make most of the difference: calling back in under five minutes, knowing what to say if nobody answers, and sending a fast quote. They also apply to exclusive leads, but are less decisive there.
| Moment | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Minute 0 to 5 | Call the person. Introduce yourself, repeat the need written in the request, offer a time slot. | The person still has their problem in mind and has often not spoken to anyone else. |
| No answer | Leave a short voice message, then send a text with your name, your trade and a time slot. | They will call back the one whose name and number they have in front of them. |
| Minute 15 | Call a second time if the request is urgent. | A first missed call does not mean a refusal: the person may have been busy. |
| Minute 30 | If a quote is possible without a visit, send it; otherwise confirm the appointment in writing. | A written quote or appointment makes your offer stand out. |
| The next day | Follow up once with those who have not replied. | Some people do not answer unknown numbers. |
A standard message, to adapt to your trade: «Hello, this is John from Example Joinery. You asked for a quote for a front door in Morges. I can come by tomorrow at 5 pm or Thursday morning to take the measurements. You can call me back on this number.» It takes twenty seconds, proves you have read the request, and gives the person a simple decision to make.
The fast quote is the third habit. In many trades, it is possible to send a price range the same day, subject to a visit, based on the information in the request and two or three photos requested by message. An honest range is better than three days of silence. It does not commit you to a final price; it shows you have understood the need.
The clauses to read in a contract
Whatever the provider, and whatever the model, the same points are worth reading before you sign. They are written in the contract or in the general terms and conditions. If one of them is missing, ask for it in writing.
- The maximum number of companies that can receive the same request, when the lead is shared.
- The exact scope of exclusivity, when there is one: which trade, which area, which municipalities or cantons.
- The conditions for keeping exclusivity: minimum balance or volume, payment period, what happens in case of delay.
- When the contact is billed: on delivery, on unlocking, on opening, on calling.
- Contesting: the time limit, the accepted reasons, what is refunded or credited back, and how.
- The unit price, what can change it, and the notice given in case of a change.
- The term of the contract, its renewal, the notice period for termination and what happens at the end.
- How the request reaches you: in full or masked, with what information, through which channel.
One point deserves particular attention: contesting. An unreachable contact, a false number, a request outside your trade or your area turn up in every channel. What matters is the procedure provided: enough time to check, written reasons, and a clearly described refund or credit.
Measuring both models over three months
The only way to decide for your company is to measure. If you receive contacts of both types, or if you change model, note the same columns each month for each. It takes no more than fifteen minutes a month if each contact is noted as it comes in, with its date, its source and what became of it.
| Column | What to note | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Contacts received | The number of requests delivered in the month | The real volume, not the announced one |
| Reached | Those you spoke to | Whether call-back time is losing you people |
| Appointments or quotes | Those for whom you made a visit or a quote | The share of genuinely useful requests |
| Signed | Quotes accepted, attributed to the month of the contact | The signing rate, the figure that is always missing |
| Spending | What the model cost you in the month | The real cost, credits deducted |
| Cost per signed customer | Spending ÷ signed | The only comparison that holds |
Two precautions make this tracking reliable. The first: attribute each signature to the month the contact arrived, not to the month the quote was signed, otherwise a project signed six weeks later distorts both months. The second: deduct credits obtained through contesting from the spending of the month concerned. After a quarter, you have your own answer, more useful than any average.
With us
To be transparent about our own model: a request is never auctioned. With exclusivity, an option by trade and by area set out in the contract, it is delivered only to you. Without exclusivity, it may also be delivered to another partner in the area, as the contract specifies. Exclusivity is kept as long as the contract runs and obligations are met, in particular a sufficient balance.
Each request arrives in full, by e-mail and in the client area, with the urgency or the time frame first and the person's message word for word. It is debited on delivery, from CHF 50; the exact price depends on the trade and the area and is set in the contract. A request that is not valid can be contested from the client area for 30 days; if the contest is accepted, the amount is credited back to the balance.
Frequently asked questions on this topic
What is an exclusive lead?
It is a contact request delivered to a single company for a given trade and area. The provider does not pass it on to anyone else. The person may still look for a quote elsewhere through other channels.
Is a shared lead a lead sold at auction?
Not necessarily. A shared lead is delivered to several companies, in a number set by the provider, at a price known in advance. An auction is a different mechanism, where the price depends on the companies' bids. Read each provider's terms.
How many companies receive a shared lead?
It depends on the provider and sometimes on the trade. The maximum number should appear in the contract or the general terms and conditions; if it does not, ask for it in writing before committing.
Is an exclusive lead always worth its price?
It is worth its price if your cost per signed customer is lower than with sharing. That is often the case for a company that cannot call back within minutes, or that sells projects where the first conversation matters more than speed.
How can I sign more with shared leads?
Call back in under five minutes, leave a voice message and a text with your name and a time slot if nobody answers, then send a price range or a written appointment the same day.
With you, is a request exclusive?
With the exclusivity option, set out in the contract by trade and by area, it is delivered only to you. Without exclusivity, it may also be delivered to another partner in the area, as the contract specifies. It is never auctioned.
